Sally Rangecroft, from the University of Birmingham University, and Niko Wanders, from Princeton and Utrecht University, explore the interconnected relationship between drought and water scarcity.
Droughts have been very much in the news recently, notably the lengthy drought in California and the impacts of El Niño on Southern Africa and the Horn and Eastern Africa. An extended drought is currently afflicting large parts of Somalia and northern Kenya, bringing with it the threat of famine.
Many people are asking whether droughts are becoming more common with climate change, and as water demand grows. How far are human activities contributing to increasing the number of, or changing the nature of, drought? And does a drought “matter” if it occurs in a place or at a time when humans are largely absent?
If we look at the impact of droughts it is even clearer that they have a severe impact on humans and that we in turn impact drought through preventative measures like building dams and increasing irrigation to support our crops. If we take a step back, we can see how inappropriate it is to think of “drought” in California and “drought” in Somalia in the same way and we start to consider more closely how we understand the concepts of drought and water scarcity.
In today’s world it is hard to find environments and regions where human activities are not impacting the natural system. As hydrologists, our work looks to incorporate a human aspect into drought understanding, processes and research. Our research also seeks to better understand how humans are changing drought hazard and impact.
But whilst it is argued that human activities are influencing drought hazard processes (e.g. water abstraction), it is important to understand that there is a difference between drought and water scarcity.
Explaining water scarcity and drought
Drought and water scarcity are intimately linked but it is obvious that water scarcity – for human-related activities – can occur without drought. Indeed, water scarcity is one of the most defining features of human societies in which poverty and marginalisation prevents people accessing water. For example, the dry climate in many regions of the Middle-East and Asia creates constant water scarcity, resulting in a high demand for irrigation, drinking water and energy production.
Droughts on the other hand, focus on the natural system and can, and do, occur when and where humans are almost completely absent. This means that, as paradoxical as it seems, droughts can occur without water scarcity.
Of course, drought and water scarcity often occur simultaneously and drought events can result in water scarcity. Drought refers to the state of the system (often quantified as when water levels fall below a certain threshold), whereas water scarcity refers to the dependence of people on that system and it only occurs when water availability is low compared to the human demand.
Drought without water scarcity
Drought therefore is often defined as a deficit in water compared to “normal” conditions of availability. Drought events normally have a large spatial extent (100-1000km) and can last from weeks, months to multi-year events (e.g. the ongoing drought in Somalia and northern Kenya). Drought can be caused by natural large-scale climatic variability, but also human activities can directly (e.g. water withdrawal, dam building, urbanization & land use change) and indirectly (e.g. anthropogenic climate change) affect the available water, leading to aggravation or alleviation of droughts.
Drought can occur in a range of variables, such as a deficit in precipitation is known as meteorological drought, a deficit in soil moisture is known as agricultural drought, and a deficit in rivers, reservoirs and groundwater is known as hydrological drought. Drought often moves from one to another type, starting as a meteorological drought and slowly propagating to agricultural and hydrological droughts, increasing in intensity and potential impact. This propagation process is slow, leading to the nickname “creeping disaster” for drought.
On the other hand, water scarcity is defined as an imbalance between water supply and water demand. Water scarcity is a deficit in the amount of available water compared to the desired amount for human use. The temporal scale can range from weekly to a permanent state due to constant over-demand.
This difference in definition is important since drought only defines the variations in the local water supply, whilst water scarcity can be impacted by both changes in supply and demand.
It is also important to disentangle the differences between drought hazard, exposure, vulnerability, risk and impacts. These concepts differ radically between locations, for example California compared to South Africa.